# Note to Mike: Simulated Sign-Off Results

## 1. Final Score & Why the Loop Stopped

- **Final Score**: **`10/10`** (in Round 6)
- **Score Progression**: `2/10` (Round 1) → `3/10` (Round 2) → `6/10` (Round 3) → `8/10` (Round 4) → `9/10` (Round 5) → `10/10` (Round 6)
- **Why the Loop Stopped**: We ran a baseline test followed by **5 distinct rounds of optimization** (6 rounds total), using a freshly spawned, isolated subagent (`dan-rater`) for every round so it could never peek at prior rounds or scores. In Round 5, we tuned the rater rubric to be even stricter—requiring named human owners for every benchmark loop and a formal public rubric-revision audit when scores diverge from 30-day team usage. The loop terminated at Round 6 once the proposal hit `10/10` under the strictest rubric.

---

## 2. Does the Proposal Still Carry Your Concern, or Did It Trade It Away?

**It preserves and operationalizes your core methodological concern (preventing false precision and earning serious credibility), while trading away the tactical blocker of freezing Vibe Check numbers until 250 tasks are built.**

### What Was Preserved (and Strengthened)
1. **Eliminating False Precision on Small-$N$ Runs Immediately**:
   Rather than excusing small sample sizes with a footnote, the final proposal enforces concrete statistical and methodological controls that Dan's persona actively supports:
   - **Locked Protocols**: Replaces ad-hoc follow-up instructions (the comparability flaw disclosed on Senior Engineer v1) with uniform, scripted follow-up protocols separated from interactive human-steered runs.
   - **Multi-Run Replication ($k = 3\text{–}5$ trials)**: Reports score spread/variance alongside the median across effort levels (high vs. extra-high) and harnesses (Codex vs. Claude Code), turning stochastic noise into a diagnostic signal (high-ceiling/high-variance vs. steady low-variance models).
   - **Blind Inter-Rater Calibration & Human Baselines**: Uses multiple blind internal raters, out-of-sample community checks, and explicit human anchors (the 89 and 96 human senior engineer baselines on Senior Engineer; Kate Lee's 30,027 historical edits, 9-of-10 recall/acceptance target, and published live accept-modify-reject rates on KateBench).
   - **Inspectable Raw Evidence**: Requires shipping full code/editorial diffs, exact prompts, end-to-end runtime durability logs (like multi-client Yjs load verification on Proof), and raw failure traces so skeptical researchers and practitioners can verify every score directly.
2. **Keeping the 250+ Task Target (and Your Ownership Over Calibration)**:
   - Instead of abandoning the 250-task threshold, the proposal wires Every's `plan-work-review-compound` loop (Compound Engineering and Compound Writing) to systematically package real Proof incidents, LFG builds, EC Bench consulting cases, and KateBench editorial passes into versioned benchmark tasks until the suite crosses **250+ consequential real-world tasks**.
   - It names you (**Mike Taylor**) as the accountable owner for **Underspecified Vibe Coding & Statistical Calibration**.

### What Was Reframed (To Win Dan's Sign-Off)
- **No Embargo on Numbers**: Simulated Dan scored Round 1 at `2/10` because holding back numbers until 250 tasks are ready clashes with his belief that articulating taste into rubrics and inspecting the tension between a score and daily team preference (like GPT-5.6 Sol scoring 56 vs. Fable's 90 while winning 9 of 9 Every testers) is the whole point of Vibe Checks.
- **Practitioners First, Not Academic Puzzle Suites**: Dan's persona does not treat academic or lab researchers as Every's primary audience and strongly opposes padding a benchmark with 250 small, synthetic puzzles that saturate quickly. By building toward 250+ tasks via **compounded real work traces** and **multi-run replication**, the proposal satisfies rigorous evaluators without compromising Every's practitioner-first identity.
