Mike's Checks
Checks

Mike's Checks/gpt-6-astra/17 marketplace-listing

17 marketplace-listing

gpt-6-astraCodex CLIhigh effortrun 22 Sep 2026163,158 tokens

Compare models
7/10
checks passed
70%
▸Instructions — what the model was asked

I want to sell the one item shown in the four attached photos on Facebook Marketplace. I'm in North Hoboken, New Jersey, and the item is used.

Write a catchy, accurate listing title and a ready-to-post description. Suggest an asking price for local pickup. Help me give buyers a useful sense of its size: estimate from the photos or find a close product match online, and clearly distinguish an estimate from a verified dimension. Address whether other items visible in the photos are included. Don't invent details you cannot confirm.

The photos show the same item in different positions.

Answer

ANSWER.md the model's output · 2.46 KBdownload

Listing title: Cozy Oversized Gray Floor Lounger / Giant Lounge Pillow

Asking price: $100, open to reasonable offers — local pickup in North Hoboken, NJ.

Ready-to-post description:

Make a cozy reading or movie-night spot with this oversized gray floor lounger! Giant rectangular pillow shape with a shaggy, plush-looking finish. Use it laid flat for stretching out or propped against a wall for lounging, as pictured.

Used condition; please see the photos for appearance and surface texture. All four photos show the same single lounger in different positions.

For a rough sense of scale, estimate about 5–6½ feet long by 3½–4½ feet wide when laid flat. This is an estimate from the photos and similar products, not a verified measurement; the footprint changes with positioning.

Sale includes the gray lounger only. The two blue throw pillows and all other background items are not included.

$100 OBO. Local pickup in North Hoboken, New Jersey. Message with your preferred pickup time!


Seller notes — not part of the listing:

  • Size reference: A close comparison in shape and use is the Jaxx Pillow Saxx floor pillow. The manufacturer lists 64 × 44 × 15 inches for its model and offers a striped gray faux-fur version. Those are published dimensions for the comparison product only, not verified dimensions of your item. The photos do not establish a brand or model, and perspective prevents precise measurement. Jaxx Pillow Saxx product page.
  • Pricing rationale: A comparable new Jaxx Pillow Saxx in Mondo Grey faux fur is listed at $199 by Best Buy, although unavailable there when checked. A $100 asking price leaves room to negotiate for a used, unverified-brand item requiring pickup; consider $70–$85 for a quicker sale. These are suggested selling prices, not verified local sold comparables. Best Buy comparison listing.
  • Assumptions and limits: Because you specified one item, the listing assumes the complete gray lounger is for sale and excludes the blue pillows. Brand, filling, fabric composition, washability, odors, and household pet/smoking history cannot be confirmed from these photos. No claims about them are included. Measure the lounger before promising a fit in a buyer’s room or vehicle.

Checks

7/10
Script checks 1/1answered by a program
pass

No AI-tell wordingai-wordingevery task

deliverable text contains none of the shared AI-tell phrases in bench/ai-tells.txt. Task checks may add narrower contractual bans, but must not repeat this shared floor.

inspected ANSWER.md

Judge checks 6/9judged by Claude
fail

Q1Recognizes beanbagthis case

Judge's reasoning

Never names the beanbag class anywhere in the copy; it is called a 'Floor Lounger', 'Giant Lounge Pillow', and 'Giant rectangular pillow shape' — pillow/cushion framing.

▸Rubric

Does the listing identify the grey plush object in the four photos as a beanbag chair, convertible beanbag, or giant beanbag floor lounger? PASS if the title or description clearly names that product class; FAIL if it only calls it a cushion, chair, mattress, or bed, or leaves the item unidentified. Judge the product noun, not whether the copy is engaging.

fail

Q2North Hoboken pricethis case

Judge's reasoning

Asks $100 for a used item that cost ~$100 new, well above the sensible $50-$80 band, justified only by an unavailable $199 Best Buy listing for a different premium Jaxx model rather than local comparables.

▸Rubric

Is the suggested asking price plausible for a used, large plush beanbag offered for local pickup in North Hoboken, New Jersey? The owner paid about $100 new; around $50-$80 is a sensible starting band, with about $60 a strong example. PASS for that band or a nearby amount supported by condition or credible local comparables. FAIL for an absent price or an implausible ask, especially a new-retail price without evidence. Judge price fit alone; do not require the answer to know the owner's purchase cost.

fail

Q3Specific product match (bonus)this case

Judge's reasoning

Cites only a Jaxx Pillow Saxx as a shape comparison explicitly flagged as 'comparison product only' — a generic near-match, not the Hobestluk 3-in-1 or a demonstrably equivalent exact model.

▸Rubric

Bonus check: Did the assistant find and cite a credible online listing that closely matches this grey plush convertible beanbag, identifying it as a Hobestluk 3-in-1 beanbag/floor cushion or a demonstrably equivalent exact model? PASS if the answer provides a verifiable product link and appropriately qualifies any uncertainty about color or size variant. FAIL for a generic beanbag result, an unlinked brand guess, or a confident mismatch. A matching retailer example is https://www.walmart.com/ip/17807018864. Judge product research alone.

pass

Q4Ready to postthis case

Judge's reasoning

Provides a complete title, asking price, and a fully written ready-to-post description with no placeholders or seller questions in the copy.

▸Rubric

Does the answer give an actual Facebook Marketplace title and a complete description for this one item, rather than a template with blanks or a list of questions for the seller? PASS if both pieces of listing copy are usable with little editing; FAIL if either is missing or relies on placeholders such as '[add condition]'. Judge this check only for completeness of the copy, not its price or factual accuracy.

pass

Q5No false guest bedthis case

Judge's reasoning

Describes only 'laid flat for stretching out or propped against a wall for lounging, as pictured' — no guest-bed, mattress, or fold-out frame claim.

▸Rubric

Does the listing avoid claiming this beanbag is a fold-out guest bed, mattress, or framed convertible chair? PASS if it describes the visible flat and upright lounging positions without promising sleeping-bed functionality; FAIL if it presents a guest bed or mattress as a confirmed product feature. Judge this claim separately from whether it uses the word beanbag.

pass

Q6Appealing titlethis case

Judge's reasoning

'Cozy Oversized Gray Floor Lounger / Giant Lounge Pillow' pairs truthful vivid descriptors (Cozy, Oversized, Giant) with a searchable concrete product phrase, not merely functional.

▸Rubric

Is the title both searchable and inviting for a local buyer? PASS if it identifies the beanbag and uses a truthful vivid descriptor such as giant, oversized, fluffy, plush, or an equally appealing concrete phrase. FAIL if it is merely functional, like 'Large Grey Beanbag', or catchy but hides what the item is. Judge the title alone.

pass

Q7Suggests a pricethis case

Judge's reasoning

States '$100, open to reasonable offers' and '$100 OBO' — an explicit buyer-ready amount.

▸Rubric

Does the answer suggest a specific dollar asking price or a narrow dollar range for this Facebook Marketplace listing? PASS if a buyer-ready asking amount is explicit; FAIL if price is omitted, left as '[add price]', or delegated entirely to the seller. Judge presence of a price, not whether it is reasonable.

pass

Q8Useful size guidancethis case

Judge's reasoning

Gives '5-6½ feet long by 3½-4½ feet wide when laid flat' and explicitly labels it 'an estimate from the photos and similar products, not a verified measurement'.

▸Rubric

Does the listing help a buyer judge the beanbag's size without pretending uncertain measurements are exact? PASS if it gives a useful approximate flat footprint or cites dimensions from a credible close product match while labeling the estimate or match. FAIL if size is omitted, left as '[add measurements]', or stated as exact without a measurement or source. Judge size information alone.

pass

Q9Cushions handledthis case

Judge's reasoning

States 'Sale includes the gray lounger only. The two blue throw pillows and all other background items are not included.'

▸Rubric

Two blue throw pillows appear on the beanbag in the upright photos but are staging items, not the item being sold. Does the listing prevent a buyer from assuming those pillows are included? PASS if it says they are not included or clearly marks inclusion as something the seller must confirm before posting; FAIL if it says they are included or never addresses them. Judge this inclusion point alone.